Ideas at Work
Building Strong Communities Through Mediation
Janet Kiser Lambarth
County Extension Agent/Chair
Washington State University Cooperative Extension
Internet Address: lambarth@coopext.cahe.wsu.edu
In the field of alternative dispute resolution, the buzzword of the mid 1980s
in the state of Washington was "mediation." The state legislature
had identified a need among its constituents for a process of resolving disputes
that was less costly and complex than the usual formal court-based adversarial
proceedings. Legislators wanted a system that encouraged voluntary participation
and that would become a model to be adopted by any community looking for an
alternative to the courts for resolving certain disputes. Mediation for dispute
resolution became the process, and the establishment of dispute resolution centers
became the vehicle for accomplishing the legislature's goals.
Washington State University Cooperative Extension entered the picture in the
early 1990s, when several Extension agents were trained and certified as professional
mediator practitioners through the established Dispute Resolution Centers. This
opened the door for Extension to develop trainings in mediation and conflict
resolution as part of Extension's community development programming. The main
audience was centered in northeast Washington, in the greater Spokane area.
The work was organized, carried out, and evaluated by the Pend Oreille County
Extension agent whose office is located in the rural county north of Spokane
and who became a professional mediator in 1994.
This article highlights a unique and very successful community development
effort that can be replicated and adapted in other communities. It elaborates
upon the reasons for focussing on Spokane and surrounding counties, explains
the actions taken by the Extension agent to create a positive reception for
mediation efforts, and discusses the impacts of a formal mediation structure
on community and personal life.
Why Mediation
Mediation is an alternative dispute resolution process that helps individuals
or groups reach a settlement of issues in a peaceful, respectful manner. The
process incorporates advanced communication, listening, and negotiation skills
to facilitate problem solving by disputants. It not only addresses solutions
for the obvious issues that lead to the conflict, but also recognizes needs
of individuals that underlie and fuel conflict. The benefits of mediation over
other forms of dispute resolution are durability of settlement, mending relationships,
personal skill-building, and increased community safetyall building blocks
for a healthier community.
Conflict (or the discrepancy between the way things are and how someone wants
them to be) is the basis for needing mediation. Conflict can be as simple as
an ordinary argument among family members over cooking dinner, to neighbors
with two different lifestyles and views of the fence line, to a former husband
and wife trying to out-compete each other for their children's loyalties. Mediation
is an excellent choice for people who expect to have continuing relationships
with each other and reputations to protect. Thus, it is particularly amenable
to community disputes that involve contractors and homeowners, neighbors, parents
and teens, landlords and tenants, merchants and customers, or managers and employees.
Settlement rates for mediation are 87% to 92%, depending on the problems mediated
and the individual or organization offering the services. In Washington, compliance
rates for settlement agreements between disputants can be 85% and higher. Settlement
agreements can be tracked because they are the only non-confidential aspect
of mediation. Agreements are signed by disputants and hold up in court.
The Situation in Spokane
In 1994, in eastern Washington, use of the mediation process was still in its
infancy. In Spokane, a city of 180,000 people and the largest city in that part
of the state, there were perhaps half a dozen certified mediator practitioners.
There was no volunteer mediator program. The courts were overloaded with small
claims cases, and the process of mediation was known to very few organizations,
businesses, or individuals that might have benefited by mediation services.
Training volunteers to mediate is a unique function of a Dispute Resolution
Center (DRC). The training program is similar in concept to Extension's Master
Gardener training program. A well-trained corps of mediator volunteers provides
invaluable assistance in reducing the court dockets of overburdened small claims
and civil court judges. It also provides services for community organizations
and families that need a neutral, safe atmosphere for discussion and problem
solving. Although there was a DRC in Spokane in 1994, there were no volunteer
mediators and no programs to train them. District Court judges were asking for
help.
The main interest of the Extension agent was to develop mediation services
for the rural county in which she worked. However, she judged that mediation
would not be easily embraced there. Building awareness and knowledge of its
value elsewhere was a step towards bringing it home. The conditions in Spokane,
50 miles away, provided that opportunity.
Actions Taken
To develop community awareness of mediation as an alternative dispute resolution
technique, an advisory committee was formed. Members were people who had a stake
in promoting mediation in Spokane. The two employees of the Spokane DRC were
invited to be part of the committee. The result was formation of the Inland
Northwest Mediation Coalition, a small, informal, representative group of mediators
in private practice, attorneys, and teaching faculty of the three area universities.
The Coalition developed a basic 40-hour mediator training course patterned
after those offered by several highly regarded DRCs in the state. Such curriculum
content generally includes conflict theory, conflict management, basic needs
theory, the eight-step mediation process, issues and interests, coached practices,
negotiations, role plays, communication and listening skills, and de-briefings.
Between 1994 and 1999, the course was marketed successfully eight times. One
hundred eleven people were trained, including 25 from rural Pend Oreille County.
Another major thrust in creating community awareness was delivering talks or
abbreviated classes to area groups. The agent made 32 of these contacts in 2
years, paving the way for the 40-hour trainings.
It was important to develop a pool of competent mediators for Spokane and surrounding
counties. The steps the Extension agent took were to:
- Become a Board member of the inactive Spokane DRC and
- Secure affiliation of the DRC with the highly regarded Volunteers of America
organization.
By becoming a Board member, she could be instrumental in developing mediator
certification standards and offering internship programs that resulted in mediator
certification. Affiliating with the Volunteers of America created the needed
organizational and financial stability for formalizing mediation resources in
the Spokane area.
Impacts of the Mediation Project
Mediation training is one of the more satisfying trainings individuals take,
according to class evaluations. At its heart is an eight-step process that is
the framework for resolution of disputes. The process recognizes what people
think is true and moves them towards identifying the real truth. Following the
eight steps creates a safe, humane, respectful environment and the opportunities
to achieve substantive, psychological, and procedural satisfaction for disputants.
Without these conditions, resolution of conflict becomes more difficult.
Among the people who took the new Spokane trainings were lawyers, law students,
school administrators, psychologists, college faculty and administrators, county
government employees, sheriff's deputies, ministers, community volunteers, industry
managers, and people looking for career changes. Also trained were 30 professionals
from the Department of Energy/Hanford Clean-Up project in Richland, Washington.
Fifty percent of all participants answered a follow-up mail survey in 1999,
helping to identify the long-range impacts of the training in their professional,
personal, and community lives.
Community Impacts
Major changes occurred in the Spokane community as a result of the mediation
trainings Extension delivered. Perhaps the most significant outcome was establishing
the Dispute Resolution Center as a legitimate program of the Volunteers of America.
The Volunteers renamed the DRC as the Inland Mediation Center (IMC), giving
it a solid financial base and staff trained by the Extension training team.
The Inland Mediation Center has been ongoing since 1996; its two Directors have
been Extension-trained. In 1997, 28 trainees were listed as volunteer mediators
with the IMC. They completed 2,404 volunteer hours of mediating. A minimum hourly
charge by professional mediators in Spokane is $60. Thus, the volunteer mediators
had donated at least $144,000 in time helping people find resolution.
Other significant Spokane community impacts in 1997 included the following.
- 178 cases were resolved with a settlement rate of 90% of all cases received
for mediation.
- The referral of 500 cases to mediation saved small claims and civil court
judges 375 hours on their court dockets.
- Judges' caseloads were reduced from 4 days to 1 1/2 days, according to the
court clerk.
Because of Extension-educated mediator volunteers, the former Spokane DRC met
its legal and professional commitments to the Spokane court system. The court
clerk reported "high satisfaction" from judges "who really push
mediation" and reported that "mediation has done well on reducing
the small claims case load."
Personal Impacts
Mediator trainees identified changes in their own behavior, actual outcomes,
and the educational value to them of the 40-hour basic training they took through
Extension. One of the more poignant testimonials was "(The training) increased
the quality of mine and my family's lives and helped my grandmother and brother
reach peace at her death."
One participant "saved my company $26,000 by using mediation for dispute
resolution. In just one instance!" In addition:
- 86% used mediation skills to prevent or deal with conflict at work.
- 22% "saved a relationship of importance to me."
- 32% used mediation skills in business situations.
- 60% used them with close family members.
- Three people started new businesses as professional mediators.
- Five people worked to start a DRC in their communities.
- Class participants referred at least 121 people to professional mediators.
- Class members recommended the class to 214 people.
- They volunteered at least 130 hours as mediators in their communities, for
a value of $7,800 in volunteer time.
In the secondary school peer mediation programs that developed for children
as a result of Extension's basic training, one rural school reported 98% durability
of settlements among students who agreed to mediate to resolve conflicts with
each other. In 1998, a principal said, "They must be mediating in the hallways
and classrooms. That is the only explanation I have for the reduced number of
discipline cases I've had in my office this year."
The Bigger Picture
A philosophical result of this Extension-sponsored educational effort has been
the establishment of the transformation style of mediation as the predominant
style practiced in eastern Washington. Transformation mediation holds the promise
of change in individuals for the betterment of society. Violence in communities
has become commonplace, as have intolerance, impatience, and a general lack
of civility.
The eight-step process Extension teaches addresses issues of justice, diversity,
leadership, environment, decision-making, change, and personal needs. The process
encourages individuals and groups to respectfully work together to solve problems.
The impact data reported here reflect personal and community change. They reinforce
mediation as an alternative dispute resolution process that encourages social
cohesion, unearths shared values, upholds fairness and equality, honors individuality,
and achieves mutual agreement. The program made a difference!
Evaluating a Diversity Educational Resource in Cooperative
Extension
Patreese D. Ingram
Assistant Professor of Agricultural and Extension Education
Internet Address:Pdi1@psu.edu
Rama Radhakrishna
Associate Professor of Agricultural and Extension Education
Internet Address: Brr100@psu.edu
The Pennsylvania State University
University Park, Pennsylvania
Introduction
The cultural landscape of American society has been changing dramatically in
the last 25 years and will continue to change. By mid-century no racial/ethnic
group in the U.S. will be in the majority. The African American, Hispanic/Latino,
and Asian American populations in this country are increasing at rates faster
than the Caucasian population (Population Reference Bureau, 2001).
The changes in the diversity of our society extend beyond race and culture.
The elderly will continue to comprise a larger segment of our population: people
85 years and older are the fastest growing age group in the nation (Brock, 2001).
Single-parent families, blended families, and other alternative family structures
are becoming commonplace; about 50% of all children born in the U.S. will spend
at least part of their childhood with only one parent (Lamb, 1999). Gay, lesbian,
bisexual, and transgender people are choosing to be open in their communities
and work places. People with physical and mental disabilities are more actively
seeking to be contributing members of society. The fastest growing religion
in this country is Islam (Arnett, 1998). And an increasing number of people
are speaking languages other than English in public settings.
The result is clear: our social institutions, including the Cooperative Extension
System, will need to change in order to effectively serve the diversity of communities
and families across this nation. The mission of Cooperative Extension is to
provide university-based educational services to communities, organizations
and families.
Description of Newsletter
In states across the country, a variety of efforts, large and small, are underway
to help build the capacity of Cooperative Extension to more effectively serve
our culturally diverse communities. In Pennsylvania, one such effort was the
development of Diverse Issues, a quarterly newsletter distributed to
Extension professionals across the state. The goal of the newsletter is to increase
an awareness of, appreciation for, and valuing of diversity. Each issue includes
five "regular topics." They are described as follows.
- Diversity in People has covered such topics as: the Amish, Arabs,
bi-racial people, alternative family structures, gays, the obese, characteristics
of rural/urban/and suburban communities, and child rearing practices of diverse
populations.
- Diversity in the Workplace focuses on issues related to working with
people who are different from oneself.
- Diversity Activity shares an activity that professionals can
use with youth and/or adult groups to help increase awareness of diversity.
- Diversity Resource provides descriptions and sources for educational
materials specifically prepared for diverse audiences, clip art depicting
diverse populations, and diversity-related web sites.
- Diversity Around the State is an opportunity to showcase the diversity
activities and efforts of Extension professionals in the counties.
The newsletter is available in both hard copy and on the Internet. Issues may
be downloaded and printed from the Web site http://AgExtEd.cas.psu.edu/FCS/pi/newsletters.html.
Ten editions of Diverse Issues were published between September, 1998
and October 2000. In an effort to evaluate the usefulness and future direction
of this newsletter as an educational resource, feedback was requested from the
readers.
Use of Diverse Issues Newsletter
We wanted to know how Diverse Issues has been used by Extension professionals
(Figure 1). One hundred and thirty-six (136) responses to this question were
received. The most frequent response was that Diverse Issues was used
as a source for personal growth and development (33%). Other uses of the newsletter
were:
- Inclusion of articles in county newsletters and other media (18%);
- Use of the activities with 4-H clubs, groups, and other Extension meetings
(16%);
- Staff development for Extension professionals and volunteers (15%);
- Use in various Extension programming efforts in the community (11%); and
- Use as a reference and resource (9%).
Figure 1.
Use of Diverse Issues
In addition to sharing the newsletter with Extension staff and 4-H youth and
leaders, respondents indicated that the newsletter is shared with Extension
advisory boards and committees, Expanded Foods and Nutrition Education Advisors,
human service agencies and organizations, various community coalitions, schools,
and church groups.
An attempt was also made to study how the newsletter has influenced diversity
programs at the county level (Figure 2). The majority (57%) of respondents indicated
that the number of county programs related to diversity issues had increased
over the past 4-5 years. For 43% of the respondents, however, the level of diversity
programming had remained the same. Some of the specific topics mentioned for
diversity programming at the county level included:
- Cultural understanding and tolerance;
- Accepting differences;
- Diversity of race, values, and socioeconomic status;
- Diversity in foods;
- Raising children from different cultures;
- Relating to others with physical challenges;
- Holiday celebrations from diverse cultures and countries;
- Acceptance of gays in the workplace;
- How we are all alike;
- Similarities among various cultural customs; and
- Requirements of the Americans With Disabilities Act.
Figure 2.
Impact of Diverse Issues
Respondents were asked a series of questions designed to reflect the impact
of Diverse Issues on Extension professionals and their programming (Figure
3). Responses suggest that with Diverse Issues Extension professions
are more likely than without Diverse Issues to:
- Use diversity information in their programming;
- Have a greater level of comfort dealing with diversity issues; and
- Have an increased level of knowledge, awareness, and understanding of diversity
issues.
A much smaller percentage, however, reported having increased requests to do
diversity programming.
Figure 3.
Impact of Diverse Issues
Outcome/Impact
The study sought to determine the usefulness and impact of a diversity-focused
newsletter as an educational resource for Extension professionals. Based on
the findings of this study, the following conclusions are drawn.
- Extension professionals consider Diverse Issues as a valued diversity
educational resource. They also agree that the content, topics, and frequency
of publication and format are appropriate.
- Extension professionals have shared Diverse Issues with other groups
in the communities. A majority of professionals indicated that the number
of programs they conduct relative to diversity has increased. The availability
of a "ready-made" resource may have been instrumental in increasing
the likelihood that Extension professionals would incorporate diversity education
into programming with community organizations and clientele.
- Diverse Issues newsletter has increased the knowledge, awareness,
and understanding of diversity-related issues. Extension professionals indicate
a greater comfort level in dealing with diversity issues.
The positive feedback from the users of Diverse Issues newsletter suggests
the need for up-to-date information on diversity-related issues. This is indeed
a significant outcome if one looks at the recent Census data and projections
for the future.
References
Arnett, E. C. (1998, January 2). Muslims entering mainstream America. Centre
Daily Times, 2, pp. A6.
Brock, J. N. (2001). The evolution of the aging population. The Aging
of America Series. Retrieved April 18, 2001 from the World Wide Web: http://www.cba.gsu.edu/magazine/aging.html
Lamb, M. E. (1999). Parental behavior, family processes and child development
in nontraditional and traditionally understudies families. In M. E. Lamb (Ed.),
Parenting and child development in nontraditional families. New Jersey:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Population Reference Bureau and Social Science Data Analysis Network
(2001). The changing American pie, 1999 and 2025. Retrieved April
2, 2001 from the World Wide Web: http://www.ameristat.org/
Strategic Planning Task Force on Diversity. (1991). Pathways to diversity:
Strategic plan for the Cooperative Extension System's emphasis on diversity.
[Working Document] USDA.
Extension Assistance for Integrated Pest Management Programs
in K-12 Schools
John C. Stier
Assistant Professor, Environmental Turfgrass Science
Internet Address: jstier@facstaff.wisc.edu
Karen A. Delahaut
IPM Specialist
Internet Address: kadelaha@facstaff.wisc.edu
Philip J. Pellitterri
Entomologist
Internet Address: pellitte@entomology.wisc.edu
R. Chris Williamson
Entomologist
Internet Address: rcwillie@entomology.wisc.edu
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Madison, Wisconsin
Brian P. Becker
IPM Coordinator
Wisconsin Dept. of Agriculture, Trade & Consumer Protection
Internet Address: Brian.Becker@datcp.state.wi.us
Introduction
Concern over children's potential exposure to pesticides has led to efforts
to ban pesticides at Wisconsin schools K-12. Legislation is pending that would
require school personnel to receive certification in Integrated Pest Management
(IPM). Three states, Massachusetts, Maryland, and Michigan, already require
IPM to be used at schools.
The University of Wisconsin-Extension (UWEX) and the Wisconsin Department of
Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection (WDATCP) developed a volunteer IPM
training program for school building and grounds managers. The goal is to help
schools develop IPM procedures to reduce children's exposure to pesticides.
The Wisconsin program is unique for two reasons. First, equal attention is
given to indoor and outdoor pest management. In most states only indoor pesticide
use is of concern. Second, while several states have developed training materials
or manuals, we provide hands-on training plus Web-based, hard copy, and telephone
support.
Program Development
In 1998, a committee of UWEX specialists, WDATCP, professional pest control
operators (PCOs), school personnel, toxicologists, and parents developed a three-part
program to encourage adoption of IPM:
- Production of a school-specific IPM manual,
- A pilot training program in 1999, and
- A full-scale program in 2000.
Phase I: School IPM Manual.
The 200-page manual provides practical information for schools to develop IPM
programs. The manual is formatted for a three-ring binder to allow pages to
be removed for photocopying and so users can add their own information, e.g.,
pesticide labels, application records, maps of school grounds, etc. Action points
are provided for each pest. An appendix contains auxiliary information such
as calibration procedures. The main sections of the manual are:
- Essential elements of IPM
- Turf management
- Outdoor insects and diseases
- Outdoor vertebrate pests
- Indoor pests
- Developing pest management plans
The manual describes proven methods to allow cost-effective implementation
of IPM such as guidelines for prioritizing needs. For example, schools often
apply fertilizer and pesticide treatments equally across the grounds, yet certain
areas are used more intensively than others and require different levels of
management (athletic fields vs. general turf areas).
School staff often lack the time and knowledge to develop the policies and
record-keeping tools needed for an IPM program. The manual contains the following
sample policies and forms that can be customized as needed.
- Pest management plan
- Pesticide use policy
- Licensing/training information
- Labels/MSDS
- Pest reporting
- Pesticide use logs
- Building/grounds maps
Pesticide selection, application, and compliance issues can be confusing to
persons not trained in pesticides. Approximately 50% of Wisconsin schools hire
professional pest control operators (PCOs), but many of them under utilize IPM.
The manual contains the following sections to ensure pesticide use is performed
in accordance with IPM guidelines.
- Posting and notification guidelines
- How to select a professional pest control operator
- Pesticide selection
The manual has been requested by dozens of schools, parks, and municipalities
in the U.S. Parts of the manual were used by a private company in Michigan for
production of a CD on school safety training. The IPM Institute of North America
has utilized the manual in production of its School IPM certification process.
The manual is available on-line at http://ipcm.wisc.edu.
Phase II: 1999 Pilot Program.
We visited six school districts three times between spring and autumn of 1999.
During the first visit we met with staff, administrators, and PCOs. We discussed
IPM, the manual, their pest problems, and conducted indoor and outdoor pest
assessments. Schools were visited 2 months later to assist in the development
of IPM plans and practices. During autumn, schools received a third visit to
assess their adoption of IPM. Eighteen other school districts received the manual
only because they wished to try IPM without assistance.
We enjoyed enthusiastic cooperation at each school we visited. All of the indoor
PCOs we met were already practicing IPM, though the schools didn't realize it.
The following examples characterize the impact of the IPM program.
- One school district quit the routine spraying of classrooms for lice, which
is an ineffective and unnecessary use of pesticide.
- Indoor insect problems at several schools ceased once food policies were
changed to restrict food to the cafeteria.
- Schools that regularly applied herbicides but didn't fertilize turf saved
money by fertilizing instead of applying herbicides.
- One school switched to dragging infields with a spiker to remove weeds instead
of using herbicides.
All of the schools we visited developed IPM policies and procedures. Of the
schools we didn't visit, only five looked at the manual and only one adopted
IPM procedures and policies.
Phase III: Full-Scale Training
The state legislature approved $55,000 to UWEX for the full-scale program in
2000. Four 1-day seminars were held during April in key suburban areas because
this is where the majority of public concerns were raised. Parents in rural
areas had minimal concern because pesticides are used routinely for farming,
while parents in inner city areas had unrelated concerns for their school-age
children.
The 250 seminar attendees were from 115 school districts (27%), representing
947 public schools (46%). School IPM manuals were given to each attendee. During
summer we provided hands-on training at 13 school districts; personnel from
nearby schools/districts were invited to participate. Approximately 200 school
personnel, representing 37 districts, attended the training sessions.
Future of Wisconsin School IPM Extension Training
Legislation proposed in 2001 may require IPM certification for school staff.
Additional funding is being sought to continue the training program.
Improving Science Education in the 4-H Geology Project
Virginia D. Bourdeau
Assistant Professor and 4-H Specialist
Oregon State University
Salem, Oregon
Internet Address: Virginia.Bourdeau@orst.edu
Introduction
Historically, Oregon's 4-H Geology project materials included a youth record
page and a 22-page combined leader/member manual. The manual provided limited
project recommendations that relied on non-Extension publications. The project's
primary focus was on the collection and display of rocks and minerals at 4-H
fairs. In 1998, only 241 youth in 19 of Oregon's 36 counties participated in
the 4-H Geology project.
Geologic formations and Earth science processes have a dynamic, and sometimes
immediate, influence on the quality of life Oregonians enjoy. The productivity
of farm, forest, and range lands is determined by the nature of their soils
and their location relative to mountain ranges and oceans that strongly influence
rainfall and watershed drainage. The Columbia River watershed drains over 250,000
square miles from the northern Rocky Mountains (a tectonic range) to the Cascades
(a volcanic range), providing water for salmon habitat, irrigation, navigation,
and hydraulic power.
An understanding of these interrelationships is important when making natural
resource management decisions. Extension Agents, teachers, and volunteers working
with youth groups needed educational resources to develop an understanding of
these geologic interrelationships.
After reviewing this situation, Oregon's 4-H Natural Science Curriculum Committee
recommended that the 4-H Natural Science Specialist convene a Task Force to
develop new geology education materials. The Curriculum Committee believed:
- Youth need a basic knowledge of geology to understand concepts important
in all natural resource projects, and
- Oregon's fascinating geology provides an opportunity to develop a science
program that goes beyond the knowledge gained creating rock and mineral collections.
A 16-member inter-agency, interdisciplinary Task Force was convened to serve
as the 4-H Earth Science Leader Guide review team. The team included
campus-based and county Extension faculty, club leaders, teens, teachers, an
after-school science club specialist, and staff from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service and U.S. Geological Survey. It was critical that the Task Force members
represent a diversity of science expertise. Reducing 365 million years of geologic
activity into an accessible format is a daunting task. When interpreting complex
concepts to youth, it is important not to make them so simplistic as to be inaccurate.
The Science-Based Leader Guide
The Task Force decided that the Leader Guide would contain lessons on basic
geologic concepts for youth in grades 4-8. These lessons would:
- Be based on the experiential learning model,
- Focus on Earth science processes using examples found in Oregon,
- Develop an understanding of the geographic and geologic interrelationships
important to natural resource management decisions,
- Be designed for multiple delivery modes including school enrichment, camps
and 4-H clubs,
- Be keyed to National Science Standards as adopted by the Oregon Department
of Education, and
- Provide opportunities to practice life skills.
The resulting 4-H Earth Science Leader Guide includes nine chapters with 27
experiential lessons. The opening chapter introduces geography and Oregon's
nine geologic provinces. In the next eight chapters the background sections
present information on Oregon's geologic history beginning in the Mesozoic and
continuing over time to recent events.
For example, the Chapter 2 background section focuses on the genesis of the
Blue Mountain Geologic Province, one of the oldest in Oregon. To assist adults
to interpret this information to youth, three experiential lessons explore the
basic science concepts:
- Convection currents,
- Density, and
- Plate tectonics.
The lessons in each succeeding chapter present additional broad Earth science
concepts, such as the rock cycle, earthquakes, and volcanism. These basic science
lessons can be used anywhere in the United States by tying concepts to a particular
region to make them most relevant to local learners.
A Leader Guide Was Not Enough
Once the 4-H Earth Science Leader Guide was completed, the Task Force
realized it was imperative to provide training to familiarize staff and volunteers
with the new materials. Specialists presented six workshops across the state
reaching 84 participants.
When asked if they would use the workshop material learned in the next six
months, 93% of participants responded "Yes." This proved to be true.
As a result of the state-wide workshops, counties that had not previously had
enrollment in the 4-H Geology project now had trained leaders who were actively
delivering the program to youth and requesting additional support.
In response to this need, Earth Science Materials Kits were developed.
The kits include chemicals, geologic models, videos, and reusable equipment
needed to conduct the lessons. In 2001, 29 of Oregon's 36 counties have access
to an Earth Science Materials Kit. Of these counties, 10 had no enrollment
in the 4-H Geology project during 1999.
Conclusion
Through the development of new geology education materials, the 4-H Natural
Science Curriculum Committee learned that a triad approach was needed to successful
launch an expanded state-wide program. This triad included:
- A science based Leader Guide,
- A materials kit to support the lessons in the Leader Guide, and
- Workshops presented by specialists to familiarize staff and volunteers with
the Leader Guide and materials kits.
In the first year, the number of youth enrolled in school enrichment or club
based 4-H Geology projects increased to 479. In addition, Agriculture and 4-H
Agents are using the Leader Guide lessons and kit materials to support other
youth education efforts. The result is both an increase in youth enrollment
in the 4-H Geology project and an increased county staff capacity to support
science education programs.
Development of a Dairy Management Information Web Site
A. M. Chapa
Extension Dairy Specialist
Mississippi State University
Mississippi State, Mississippi
Internet Address: achapa@ads.msstate.edu
J. W. Smith
Extension Dairy Scientist
Internet Address: jimsmith@arches.uga.edu
L. O. Ely
Extension Dairy Scientist
Internet Address: laneely@arches.uga.edu
W. D. Gilson
Extension Dairy Scientist
Internet Address: wgilson@arches.uga.edu
M. Nakazawa
Graduate Student
Internet Address: nakazawa@ai.uga.edu
University of Georgia
Athens, Georgia
Introduction
The Internet has transformed the way people access information and has created
opportunities for distribution of general and scientific information in areas
such as education, business, government, and health care (Lawrence & Giles,
1999). However, a major disadvantage of an Internet search is the time required
to sift through a myriad of unorganized sites returned from a typical search
to find pertinent information.
The amount of publicly available information on the Web has increased rapidly
(Lawrence & Giles, 1998b). The Web's doubling period was under 3 months the
second half of 1993, nearly 5 months in 1995, and under 6 months during 1997
(Gray, 1997). The percent of commercial sites increased in a 4-year period from
1.5% of all sites in 1993 to nearly 63% in 1997 (Grey, 1997). Estimates from
February 1999, showed the publicly indexable Web containing approximately 800
million pages, with 83% of the sites containing commercial content and 6% containing
scientific content (Lawrence & Giles, 1999). Because of the Web's rapid growth
and dynamic nature, search engine coverage relative to size has decreased since
December 1997, with no search engine indexing more than approximately 16% (Lawrence
& Giles, 1999). For a truly comprehensive index, all pages would have to be
indexed simultaneously. Currently, this is not possible. (Lawrence & Giles,
1999).
Two approaches can be used when searching the Web. Subject guides (Yahoo, LookSmart)
are commonly used for general topics, while search engines (Alta Vista, Northern
Light) are better suited for finding specific information. A common complaint
regarding search engines is the return of numerous pages containing irrelevant
material. The results of a search are influenced by various factors, including
database size, update frequency, search capability and design, and speed. Indexing
new or modified pages by a search engine can take months. Lawrence and Giles
(1999) found that search engines are more likely to list commercial sites than
educational sites and sites that have more links. Therefore, the more "popular"
sites are more apt to be listed in search results.
Another disadvantage of an Internet search is lack of quality control. Although
there are over 100 peer-reviewed science, technical, and medical journals available
online (Taubes, 1996) and many institutions review material before it is placed
on a Web site, no formal review process exists for indexing a Web site on the
Internet. Therefore, sites can be biased, misrepresent facts, or contain little
factual information. Users must not only consider the relevance of the information
to their current situation, location, and resources, but also the credibility
of the Web site.
Development and Use of the Dairy Management Web Site
Information on the Internet pertaining to the dairy industry comes from a variety
of sources, including but not limited to:
- Universities and colleges,
- Private industry,
- Magazines,
- Breed organizations, and
- The federal government.
Not all resources are linked, and deciding where and how to start searching
can be a challenge. "The Dairy Manager" Web site was developed in an attempt
to simplify finding and delivering reliable dairy management information to
dairy producers and county Extension educators (http://www.ads.uga.edu/groups/dairy).
A panel of experts in various fields, including dairy nutrition, reproduction,
veterinary medicine, agricultural engineering, and farm management review materials
prior to placement on this site. "The Dairy Manager" consists of a compiled
list of reviewed, specific, current dairy management reference Web sites. Each
reference Web site is listed by title, description of contents, and keywords.
Reference Web sites on "The Dairy Manager" are from private industry, government
agencies, and public institutions. Most of the information on "The Dairy Manager"
comes from university sources such as Extension bulletins, circulars, newsletters,
and other publications. The rural market presents challenges in designing an
effective Web site. Examples include reliability of telephone service and dated
computer hardware and software (Samson, 1998). "The Dairy Manager" is designed
to consider the limitations of the rural market. A simple Web-page layout and
limited graphics allow for faster loading and access.
The initial "Welcome" page summarizes announcements or changes, allows users
to choose the navigation method, and provides links that may be of importance
to the dairy producer. Two methods of navigating "The Dairy Manager" are available.
The "Search" feature searches lists of keywords in an internal database of reference
Web sites for a match. The search engine searches reference Web sites listed
within "The Dairy Manager," not the entire Web, with results displayed as a
list of relevant Web sites containing the specified keyword(s).
The Directed Browsing feature consists of various topics. Users can look for
information regarding "Livestock Management," "Forage Production and Management,"
"Labor and Business Management," or "Articles in Spanish." In order to narrow
the choices, these categories are subdivided into additional topics such as
"milking herd," "calves," "forage production," and "labor management." The livestock
topics are subdivided into areas covering "nutrition," "health," "housing,"
and "management." Some sites may relate to numerous topics, therefore, a Web
site may be listed under more than one topic and subtopic.
To access the information described in the reference Web site, a link "points"
to the specific site. By clicking on the link, the reference Web site is opened
onto a new window. "The Dairy Manager" is intended to provide current information
and is updated frequently, with out-of-date information removed. "The Dairy
Manager" currently contains 300-plus individual reference Web sites. Since its
release in April 1999, the site has logged approximately 4,700 hits, averaging
400 hits per month. Counters on the Search page and Directed Browsing page indicate
that the Search feature is used twice as much as the Browsing. Although "The
Dairy Manager" presently contains information focused on management topics,
future expansion is planned.
Conclusion
The "Dairy Manager" Web site is an attempt to simplify the process of finding
dairy information for producers and county Extension educators. By incorporating
two methods of navigating the site and linking to specific articles, users can
use time more efficiently. Although face-to-face meetings, hands-on workshops,
and demonstrations remain the mainstays of Extension, new technology and electronic
media can provide opportunities to university and county Extension educators
for innovative and cost-effective ways of information distribution to producers
(Latour & Meunier, 1999).
References
Grey, M. (1997). Measuring the growth of the Web: June 1993 to January 1997
[On-line]. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Available at: http://www.mit.edu/people/mkgray/growth
Latour, M. A., & Meunier, R. A. (1999). Transferring poultry information to
the public using the Internet: AvianNet@Purdue University.Journal of Extension
[On-line] 37(5) Available at: http://www.joe.org/joe/1999october/iw1.html
Lawrence, S. & Giles, C. L. (1998). Searching the World Wide Web. Science.
280, 98-100.
Lawrence, S. & Giles, C. L. (1999). Accessibility and distribution of information
on the Web. Nature. 400, 107-109.
Lawrence, S. & Giles, C. L. (1999). Searching the Web: General and scientific
information access. IEEE Comm. 37, 116-122.
Samson, S. A. (1998). Technological issues of improving access to Internet
Web sites for rural users. Journal of Extension [On-line] 36(4). Available
at: http://www.joe.org/joe/1998august/tt2.html
Taubes, G. (1996). Science journals go wired. Science. 271, 764-766.
Training and Supporting Volunteer Mentors for Juvenile Offenders
in Urban Gardening
Joseph H. Konen
District Specialist, Urban Programs
Ohio State University Extension, Northeast District
Wooster, Ohio
Internet Address: konen.2@osu.edu
Adult volunteers are the head, heart, and hands of a healthy 4-H mentoring
project with juvenile offenders. The Green Team Project is a 3-year partnership
of Extension's 4-H and Urban Gardening programs and the Cuyahoga County Juvenile
Court for urban gardening with juvenile offenders.
Volunteer selection, training, and support are important aspects of the program.
This article gives an overview of the Green Team Program and then shares the
volunteerism lessons gleaned from the 3 years of experience.
1998 was the first year of 4-H volunteer involvement in the Green Team. Following
a research design, 30 juvenile offenders were randomly selected from a pool
of 60 designated by the court. The 30 Green Team youths were to garden twice
a week for 5 months. A team of 40 volunteers was selected and trained to work
with the youths in teams of one or two youths with an adult.
In 1999 and 2000, the program was modified from the original research model,
and the court referred selected youths for community service with the Green
Team, generally for 20 hours each. Gardening was on Tuesday evenings for 2 hours
and on Saturday mornings for 3 hours. Again adults were matched with youths
in teams of two or three.
Table 1.
Youth and Volunteer Participation in the Green Team Project, 1998 to 2000
|
Year
|
Total Youths
|
Total
Youth Hours
|
Total Adults
|
Total
Adult Hours
|
|
1998
|
27
|
1,117
|
33
|
775
|
|
1999
|
119
|
1336
|
71
|
1343
|
|
2000
|
44*
|
483*
|
40*
|
359*
|
* statistics through August 1, 2000.
|
Volunteer Recruitment was handled through word of mouth, through a request
to the Master Gardeners program, and through newspaper and other media articles
and announcements. Many volunteers have returned year after year. As is evident
through the statistics, in the second year there were many short-term volunteers.
Volunteers come with a variety of backgrounds. Some are Master Gardeners or
others with a high interest in gardening. Others have little gardening experience
but have a high motivation to serve and help the youth in the Green Team.
Volunteer selection over the 3 years was based on an application process that
included a formal application, signing of a volunteer standards of behavior
and youth protection policy, a reference check, and an interview with a Green
Team staff member. In 2000, a police background check, conducted through the
county, was added.
Volunteer training has evolved and will continue to be modified as experience
dictates. In 1998, volunteers participated in an 18-hour training process that
included 6 hours of garden training and 12 hours of the Training Program
for Leadership of Youth Groups designed by a task force of the Association
of Social Work with Groups. Youth-serving professionals with social work and
educational backgrounds presented the program.
1998 Orientation Schedule
Group Formation Activities2 hours
Understanding Youth Today
Developmental and Social Issues of youth Today2 hours
Societal Issues Impacting Youth Today2 hours
Understanding Youth Groups
Group Process2 hours
Group Leadership2 hours
Adult Leaders of Youth
Standards of Behavior and Liability for Volunteers2 hours
Burn-out and Support for Volunteers2 hours
Garden Training Sessions4 hours
This ambitious training program was of great benefit to some volunteers and
considered overkill by some with social work or education backgrounds. In reducing
the orientation to two sessions for the 1999 and 2000 seasons, we yielded to
the request of many applicants to enter the program more easily. We supplemented
the basic training with more on-the-job training.
Perhaps, in the process, we have sacrificed some up-front team building and
understanding of the process of group development. We balanced this by bringing
the experiences of the current volunteers into the training as each topic was
covered. We have supplemented the group process training by ongoing reflections
on the process as each gardening session is debriefed. The orientation and training
has evolved to this:
2000 Orientation Schedule
Orientation Session2 hours
- History of the Green Team effort and 2000 Plans
- Green Team YouthWho are they and how are they sent by the court
- 2000 Green Team Daily Work Plan: Welcome, Ice- Breakers, Team Formation,
Work Assignments, Break, Clean-up, Dismissal, Debriefing
- Structure and Behavior Guidance: What are the rules and how to handle
infractions and problems
- Youth Development Reflections from the book The Nurture Assumption
by Judith Harris and volunteer stories of positive encounters while gardening
Garden Training2 hours.
Additional, ongoing training for volunteers has been through the 3-hour video
conference Youth Starts with You, which centers on Relationship, Behavior
Guidance, Motivating, and Communicating.
Key to the success of the program has been the work of the Green Team coordinator,
who has served as a liaison with the juvenile court, as volunteer coordinator
for the project, and as the facilitator of activities at the garden site. The
position has been held by both Extension program assistants (paid for with grant
money) and, in 2000, by a court employee with a strong social work background.
The court's willingness to support the Green Team community service project
in this way is a positive sign of the value of the program.
A key element of this coordinator's work is to match the youths and volunteers
and to facilitate the beginning, break, and closing of the sessions. Fortunately,
the strong leadership of the Extension Urban Gardening staff has directed the
gardening plans and work. This allows the coordinator to focus on communication
with volunteers and youths.
Volunteers bring their own special talents: story-telling, conversation, bringing
special foods from their home garden, initiating a game of horse-shoes at a
break, or telling about their own career path. Volunteers come with a variety
of abilities to relate and form a bond with the youths. Coaching and developing
such skills is the responsibility of the Green Team staff. Volunteers are expected
to work at strong contact with the youth during gardening activities but are
discouraged from contact privately with youth outside garden activities.
The Green Team is youth development at its best: creating positive relationships
between adult volunteers and youths in an activity valued in the community.
References
RISE Learning Solutions (1999). Youth starts with you, 10490 Taconic
Terrace, Cincinnati, OH.
Association for the Advancement of Social Work With Groups. (1998). A Training
program for leadership of youth groups, Second Edition, 210 pp. AASWG, Inc.C/O
The University of Akron.
Building Partnerships to Address Challenging Social Problems
Kerry Kazura
Associate Professor, Family Studies
University of New Hampshire
Durham, New Hampshire
Internet Address: Kerry.Kazura@unh.edu
Mary Temke
Extension Specialist Human Development
University of New Hampshire Cooperative Extension
Durham, New Hampshire
Internet Address: Mary.Temke@unh.edu
Kristina Toth
Program Administrator
Department of Corrections
Laconia, New Hampshire
Internet Address: familyresourcecenter@yahoo.com
Barbara Hunter
Extension Educator, Family Development
University of New Hampshire Cooperative Extension
Laconia, New Hampshire
Internet Address: Barbara.Hunter@unh.edu
Introduction
A parent in prison creates disruption and stress for the entire family system.
In the United States over 1.7 million people are currently incarcerated in jails
and prisons (Gilliard & Beck, 1998). More than one half of state and federal
inmates are between the ages of 18 and 34 (Gilliard & Beck, 1998). Approximately
65% of inmates have children under the age of 18, and 6% of women entering prison
are pregnant. Currently, nearly 1.5 million children have a mother or father
in federal or state prison (Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2000).
There is evidence that family support for inmates during incarceration, either
informal or programmatic, promotes positive behavior during incarceration and
reduces the likelihood of recidivism (Borgman, 1985; Fishman, 1982; Schafer,
1994). There is also evidence that children with incarcerated parents are at
risk and need support to reduce the likelihood of intergenerational criminal
behavior (Adalist-Estrin, 1994).
The Family Connection Project
Because of the high incidence of incarceration and the family issues associated
with incarceration, a partnership was created among the University of New Hampshire
(UNH) Cooperative Extension, UNH Department of Family Studies, and New Hampshire's
Department of Corrections (Kazura, Baber, & Temke, 1999). This partnership
is called The Family Connection Project. Programming objectives are to
strengthen at-risk families and improve the healthy development of children
with incarcerated parents through a family-centered, strength-based approach.
The acquisition of positive family and relationship skills is expected to increase
protective factors and decrease risk factors in families with an incarcerated
parent.
The participants of this program are parents incarcerated at a New Hampshire
state correctional facility and their families. At the current time, the prison
population is approximately 500 (450 men and 50 women). A recent study by Kazura
(1999) indicated that 73% of the prison inmates are parents (or stepparents),
and 58% receive visits from their children.
The correctional facility houses a state-of-the-art rehabilitation program
established in 1993. The facility serves non-violent offenders; the majority
of offenders committed crimes associated with drug and alcohol use. It offers
inmates two programs: 1) a modified therapeutic community, to deal with inmates'
substance abuse; and 2) a vocational college program, to assist the inmates
with their education and employment needs.
Needs Assessment
Respondents to a needs assessment survey were inmates who either had children
or expected to return to homes with children (e.g., partners' children, siblings'
children) upon being released from the facility. One hundred thirty-six inmates
(99 male, 37 female) who ranged in age from 18 to 49 (M=29.33, SD=7.67) completed
the needs assessment.
The assessment asked inmates to indicate their:
- Needs for education concerning parenting issues,
- Needs for life skills training,
- Concerns regarding finances,
- Needs for visitation programs,
- Partners' need for information about the correctional facility, and
- Needs and their partner's needs for social support services.
Kazura (1999) found that inmates realized and were concerned about how their
incarceration was affecting their children's social and emotional development.
Many inmates requested information about how to deal with their children's stress
and what signs to look for in their children's behavior that may demonstrate
the impact of incarceration and/or separation. In addition to parenting issues
related to incarceration, these parents wanted basic parenting education concerning
discipline and caring for their children. This group of inmates seemed to be
motivated to be more knowledgeable and skillful parents; however, there were
little to no resources available to them.
Four Programming Strategies Developed from the Needs Assessment
Parent Education Classes
The majority of inmates receive parenting education classes that were designed
for parents of young children, school age children, and adolescents. UNH Cooperative
Extension trains program staff to conduct their parenting education program,
Family Focus (Temke, 2000a; 2000b; 2001). Parents learn about child growth and
development, effective discipline, positive communication, supporting children's
education, building self-esteem in children, problem solving, decision making,
and developing responsibility in children.
Parent Support Groups
Inmates are encouraged to attend parent support/education groups. Program staff
and students from the UNH Department of Family Studies are trained to conduct
informal parenting support groups for incarcerated parents. In the near future
similar support groups will be offered to the inmates' spouses/partners.
Supervised Parent-Child Visitation
A section of the correctional facility has been renovated for supervised visitations
between the incarcerated parents and their children. A play room has been designated
for parents to interact with their infants, toddlers, preschoolers, and/or young
elementary school children. A recreation room has been created for parents to
interact with their children who are school-age and adolescents. There are one-way
mirrors in each of these rooms so parents may be observed.
A faculty member from the UNH Department of Family Studies trains advanced
graduate students and program staff to work in the playroom and recreation room
with parents and children in order to model appropriate adult/child interaction.
Students also observe parent-child interactions via the one-way mirrors and
provide feedback to the parents regarding their parenting style.
Community Outreach via Cooperative Extension
Currently, program staff are partnering with 4-H Youth Development educators
in the 10 New Hampshire counties to enroll children of incarcerated parents
into community 4-H clubs or other youth development programs. In addition, the
program staff works with UNH Cooperative Extension's family development educators
to connect spouses/partners to parenting education programs and social services
in their communities.
Outcomes
Each of these programming strategies will be extensively evaluated for effectiveness.
Expectations are that the data will demonstrate that this is an important program
that addresses the risk and protective factors associated with this marginalized
population. In addition, it has the potential to lower recidivism and break
the cycle of intergenerational transmission of behavior that leads to incarceration.
Acknowledgment and Disclaimer
Cooperative agreement number 5U1FSPO8169-02 made funding for The Family
Connection Project and this publication possible from the Substance Abuse
and Mental Health Services Administration's Center for Substance Abuse Prevention.
The contents are solely the responsibility of the authors and do no necessarily
represent the official views of the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services
Administration's Center for Substance Abuse Prevention.
References
Adalist-Estrin, A. (1994). Family support and criminal justice. In S. L. Kagan
& B. Weissbourd (Eds.) Putting families first: America's family support
movement and the challenge of change (pp. 161-186). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
Publishers.
Bureau of Justice Statistics. (2000). Incarcerated parents and their children
(BJS Document No. NCJ182335). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Borgman, R. (1985). The influence of family visiting upon boys' behavior in
a juvenile correctional institution. Child Welfare, 64(6), 629-638.
Fishman, S. H. (1982). The impact of incarceration on children of offenders.
Journal of Children in Contemporary Society, 15, 89-99.
Gilliard, D., & Beck, A. J. (August, 1998). Prisoners in 1997. Bureau
of Justice Statistics Bulletin. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
Kazura, K. (2001). Family programming for incarcerated parents: A needs assessment
among inmates. Journal of Offender Rehabilitation, 32, 67-83.
Kazura, K., Baber, K., & Temke, M. (1999). The Family Connection Project:
A collaborative approach to supporting families with incarcerated parents. Family
Science Review, 12, 294-315.
Schafer, N. E. (1994). Exploring the link between visits and parole success:
A survey of prison visitors. International Journal of Offender Therapy and
Comparative Criminology, 38(1), 17-32.
Temke, M. (2000a). Family Focus: parenting the young child (Rev. ed.).
NH: University of New Hampshire, Cooperative Extension.
Temke, M. (2000b). Family Focus: parenting the school age child (Rev.
ed.). NH: University of New Hampshire, Cooperative Extension.
Temke, M. (2001). Family Focus: parenting the young teen (Rev. ed.).
NH: University of New Hampshire, Cooperative Extension.
This article is online at
http://joe.org/joe/2002february/ent-iw.html.
Copyright © by Extension Journal, Inc.
ISSN 1077-5315. Articles appearing in the Journal become the property of the
Journal. Single copies of articles may be reproduced in electronic or print form
for use in educational or training activities. Inclusion of articles in other
publications, electronic sources, or systematic large-scale distribution may be
done only with prior electronic or written permission of the Journal Editorial Office, joe-ed@joe.org.
|